Closet Core vs Simplicity: Which Patterns Are Right for You?
Closet Core and Simplicity represent two very different approaches to sewing patterns — one indie, one commercial; one curated, one massive. Both produce excellent patterns, but they serve different needs. Here's a head-to-head comparison to help you decide where to spend your time and money.
Love this guide? Get more like it.
Join 1,200+ sewists. Early access + 10% off when we launch.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Category | Closet Core | Simplicity |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $15-$22 per pattern | $5-$15 (often $1.99 on sale) |
| Format | PDF + print-at-home | Tissue paper (store) or PDF |
| Instructions | Photo-illustrated, detailed | Line-drawn, step-by-step |
| Skill Level | Intermediate-Advanced | Beginner-friendly |
| Size Range | 0-20 (some full bust) | 6-28W |
| Catalog Size | ~25 patterns | Thousands |
| Style | Modern wardrobe staples | Wide variety, classic to trendy |
| Community | Active sew-alongs, social | Large but less engaged |
Choose Closet Core If...
- You want modern, on-trend wardrobe staples
- You prefer photo-illustrated instructions
- You're comfortable with intermediate-level techniques
- You want to join an active sewing community
- You care about the designer's aesthetic and brand story
Choose Simplicity If...
- You're a beginner and want guided instruction
- You need extended sizing (up to 28W)
- You want variety — thousands of styles to choose from
- Budget matters — $1.99 pattern sales can't be beat
- You want tissue paper patterns without printing
The Verdict
There's no wrong choice — most sewists end up using both. Start with Simplicity to build your skills and confidence, then explore Closet Corewhen you're ready for more challenging, design-forward projects. The best pattern is the one that matches your current skill level and the garment you want to make.
Shop both on Make & Sew
We're carrying indie and commercial brands side by side. Join the waitlist.